Catholic Online features an extensive number of pages on various aspects of Catholicism including 'Prayers', 'Saints and Angels' and 'Home & Family'. Today I have decided to explore the section entitled Catholic Life. I would suggest that the term "Catholic Life" is an exceptionally broad one and the links from the page reflect this!Topics covered on this page range from Prayers&Beliefs and Church Terms to Our Lady of Guadeloupe and Mother Teresa. Some of the links divert to other sites (for example the link Holy Bible directs you to the New American Bible site) but most direct you to pages within Catholic Online. Catholic Online does not feature anything that marks it as an "official" Catholic Church website, not even the name or crest of a paticular Diocese. As I stated in the last post, I believe that this a website for Catholics rather than a tool of evangelization but I am sure that non-Catholics would look to this site if searching for something about Catholicism - whether it be for interest or for information. Google does not discern the intention of the site in matching up searched words to websites! This is a concern because the content of the website may be taken as authoritative on aspects of the Catholic Faith when in fact it may not be.The term Popes features on the Catholic Life page. When clicking on the link you are given two more options: Pope John Paul II and Benedict XVI. Though there is certainly more than one Pope featured on this page, it seems to have neglected to provide information on the hundreds of other Popes that have lived! And in fact, when clicking on the links for the two Popes featured on the page, you are directed to very different pages. The page for Pope John Paul II is headed with the title "Pope John Paul II 1920-2005 - The Pope of Popes" and includes another 26 links to articles about his life, his Encyclicals, Canonizations and special prayers for the late Pope. The link for Pope Benedict XVI directs you to a page entitled "Email Pope Benedict XVI" with absolutely no information or anything else to do with His Holiness. The creators of this website are thereby expressing a bias towards the late Pope and his teaching. This website is updated very regularly (every time I have visited the home page the "last updated" date has been that day's date) yet this section of the website seems to have been neglected.
This website is an example that the information published on the internet is not necessarily authentic or properly verified. The bias of the website designers to Pope John Paul II seems obvious to the Catholic reader but could be interpreted by the non-Catholic reader as Pope John Paul II as somehow being a “better” Pope. It could even be understood that he is liked more by all Catholics as the website is called Catholic Online – though it only represents the work of a small group of Catholics it is presented under an all encompassing name.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
The notion of how one analyses how true to an organised religion a website is an interesting one. Clearly, if many people use the Internet for information about religions, and there is no means of determining how "official" a site it, there is scope for confusion and the adoption of false ideas about another religion.
Obviously there are certain ways people know the extent to which they can trust a site - such as a ".va" site is only going to come from a server in the Vatican, and a ".gov" or ".edu" are other examples of perhaps more trustworthy sites. But I wonder how many Internet users are actually aware of this when they surf the Internet?
Your take on the leaning of the site is interesting, the creators of the site appear to be losing their objectivity in this respect. It is interesting what Newman said on the previous comment about the trustworthiness of a site - when I first visited Catholic Online, the thing that reassured me was the fact that the site ended with '.org', sites with this suffix are often seen as more authoritative, e.g. oxfam.org.uk, cafod.org.uk or britishcouncil.org. Maybe others feel the same?
Post a Comment